Here are some hotels that give you an option of going all-inclusive or just going EP. All are reasonably priced.
Legends and Sam Sara
Legends is located on the beach, Sam Sara is on the cliffs. There is a free shuttle that will take you back and forth each day. A nightly happy hour at sunset, and close to everything.
Merril's I, II + III
All properties are located on the beach close to each other. The properties are small with true a Jamaican flavor.
Coral Seas Garden Resort
Located on the morass side close to Negril's town center and craft market.
Located on a perfect stretch of white sand this EP hotel offers AI packages at affordable rates.
This small inn has a daily shuttle to the beach. Located off the Westend Rd, this little inn will make you feel like you are part of the family. Extremely affordable EP rates, as well as AI rates.
Sunset on the Beach and Cliffs Resorts
*Formerly Coral Sea's Resorts*
The beach side resort is close to Negril's center, and to the craft market. Both beach and cliff resorts offer all inclusive or EP packages at reasonable prices. As well as rooms with kitchenettes. As sister resorts you can exchange privileges at each.